60 pages • 2 hours read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
On Makatea, Ina builds something out of recovered garbage. She doesn’t know what she’s building, except that she has “a monster growing in her yard” (207). Later, she takes her family on a picnic and collects more garbage for her project. She watches the children as Rafi mentions that “this little family officially controls five percent of the say over Makatea’s future” in the referendum (209). He neither wants to disturb the island’s status quo or decide the locals’ fate on their behalf. He feels like they’re “condemned to choose” (211). They wonder how their two children will vote. When their sacks are filled with plastic, they head home.
Todd recalls the time he spent with Ina and Rafi. She had the idea of a “lecture series” in which each of them would deliver a lecture to the other two about the thing that meant most to them. Rafi was reluctant but went through with the idea to please Ina. Todd remembers spending time with his mother in her small apartment, when she didn’t want to talk about the ways that his father (her husband) “messed [them] both up, badly” (218). For his lecture, Todd introduced Ina and Rafi to CRIK, the supercomputer with the early AI model. He preloaded information about the Pacific Islands to impress Ina, who was more taken back by the art database on the proto-internet system. He told his friends about his deep love for computers, though Rafi cast doubt on Todd’s reasons for doing so.
Rafi reluctantly attended Ina’s lecture, where she showed off her studio. In the center of the room was a “massive 3D collage” resembling a totem (222). She explained the sculpture’s significance with regard to her identity as a Pacific Islander and a daughter and then dashed the sculpture with blue paint. At first, Todd was horrified, but then he saw the watery effect of the paint and realized that Ina had made him and Rafi part of the performance and creation of the final piece.
Finally, Rafi had to deliver his lecture. He took his friends into his private room at the back of the library, which was full of esoteric old books. Rafi read from his unfinished poems, sonnets about his guilt for breaking up his parents’ marriage and the death of his sister. Ina kissed Rafi, and Todd slipped outside. Afterward, they attended a performance of Shakespeare’s The Tempest. The play moved Ina to tears, and as they walked home in wintery conditions, she was astonished to see snow for the first time. Not long after this, Todd had “the brainstorm that would shape the rest of [his] life” (235). Rafi moved out of the dorm and in with Ina while he pursued a postgraduate degree in American literature. Todd saw Rafi less frequently.
At 36, Evelyne struggled to come to terms with her realization about her sexuality. She believed that Bart was “the world’s most gentle and accommodating man” (236), with whom she had two children. She also had a career to think about at a time when lesbian sexuality could threaten to limit her professional prospects. A picture magazine commissioned her to author an article about Truk Atoll, a part of the ocean that is an “immense graveyard” for the sunken ships of World War II. Thinking that the article might bring closure for her mother, who mourned the wartime loss of her brother at sea, Evelyne accepted the commission. As ever, Bart stayed at home to manage the household and his career. Evelyne dove down amid the wrecks and discovered a paradise of life: Fish, plants, and coral thrived in the reclaimed environment. She swam between the scuttled ships and the dead sailors, snapping photos of sharks. When she returned, she wrote to her mother about the “final resting place” of her Uncle Phillipe and then wrote the article, which referenced Arial’s song from The Tempest (243). Four years later, after her mother’s death, Evelyne found a copy of the article in her mother’s house.
Todd remembers the early years of his career as his “golden age.” He spent all his time on software development, working on the early versions of what eventually became Playground. He didn’t see much of Rafi, Ina, or anyone else, nor did he have time for romantic relationships. He was tangentially aware of Rafi working on his thesis and Ina sculpting a canoe from a fallen tree.
One day, when he and Rafi met for lunch, Todd talked about his plans for Playground as a giant social media network where people could interact with one another. Rafi gave him an important piece of advice: “[G]amify it.” In an excited frenzy, they sketched out the initial drafts of the systems that made Playground so addictive. They drew on their history of competitive game playing, narrative, and human psychology. By the meeting’s end, Todd was quite excited. He offered to bring Rafi onboard, telling him that “there were fortunes to be made” (252), but Rafi turned him down. The rejection hurt Todd, but he threw himself into work on Playground. He soft-launched the software, which proved as addictive as Rafi said it would be. Around this time, Ina emailed Todd. She was concerned about Rafi, who had delayed finishing his thesis for unknown reasons. Todd, “still bitter” about Rafi’s rejection, didn’t go to see him.
While living with Ina, Rafi receives a late-night phone call from his mother. He’s yet to tell her about his plans to propose to Ina. His mother worries about his prospects for the future. She encourages him to come and work with her in government administration. Rafi knows that such a career would be the death of him but can’t explain this to her. He doesn’t know how to tell anyone that he’s happiest researching and rewriting his thesis; he doesn’t want to finish it. He returns to bed and, three months later, his mother dies.
Todd tells his AI device about the Playground launch. He showed his professor, who helped him secure funding options. Investors offered vast sums of money, but he chose the option that allowed him to retain control of the company. When he started his company, he employed five people, but it rapidly expanded. Amid the chaos of the launch, Ina appeared in his apartment, distraught because Rafi seemed as though he’d never submit his thesis. Ina described an argument she had with him, in which she threatened to leave town without him unless he submitted his thesis.
Todd recognized his own competitiveness with Rafi at the root of her complaints. He described to her the deep guilt that Rafi felt over his sister’s death and the end of his parents’ marriage, incidents that Rafi had spoken about only with Todd. As the night drew on, Todd invited Ina to stay with him. When he insisted that he sleep on the floor and she in the bed, she realized that he was in love with her. She said nothing. In the morning, Rafi arrived at Todd’s apartment. Todd knew that Rafi felt betrayed that his two closest friends were meeting behind his back. When Ina revealed what Todd told her about Rafi’s guilt, Rafi left. He refused “to be analyzed by two people who have no clue” (267). Ina chased after Rafi. Todd didn’t hear from Rafi again despite his attempts to reach out. All he received from Ina was a plea to “stop making things worse” (268). Todd learned that Ina went to Tahiti, while Rafi moved into a tenement building.
Around this time, Todd’s burgeoning success demanded that he move to San Francisco. Before he went, Todd made one last effort to speak to Rafi. The meeting was terse and unproductive. When Todd moved to California, he wrote to Rafi regularly. From afar, he learned that Rafi submitted his thesis. The messages remained unanswered, so Todd threw himself into work, making success his “vindication and revenge” (271). Now, Todd speaks to the AI device as a product of this long work process. He believes that he’s on the cusp of “raising all the dead” (271).
The Makatean people prepare for the referendum. Didier asks Palila to invite a remote hermit to the vote since she’s the only person he’ll talk to. Didier visits Ina and Rafi to invite them to another meeting. He sees Ina’s garbage sculpture and feels that it’s powerful but doesn’t understand why. During the visit, he thinks about the two children. Their actual parents were Makatea natives who died tragically. Rafi and Ina adopted the children, offering to raise them on the island. They’re “old enough to be the children’s grandparents” (274). Palila visits the hermit, Tamatoa, with whom she has a romantic past. Tamatoa lives remotely and hates outsiders. Palila invites him to share his feelings at the community meeting.
At his house, Didier talks to Roti about the vote. She eases his anxieties, and he appreciates her even more. Later, he visits Evelyne, whom he finds teaching Kinipela to play the piano. In the following days, Didier prepares the presentation using technology that the US consortium sent him. He’s nervous as he stands before his constituents. The short computer-generated promotional video impresses Makatean residents through the lure of lavish homes and promises of development. The “clever” marketing impresses Didier. Afterward, the residents debate the film’s merits and intentions. They have many unanswered questions. In addition to stacks of literature, Didier says, the consortium provided access to a prepared AI machine named Profunda to answer their questions. They boot it up. The machine gives in-depth and honest answers to their “fast and furious” questions and impresses the residents (288), especially when it admits that Kinipela’s concerns about negative effects on the local wildlife are justified. The residents spend the next week bombarding the AI machine with questions.
In the following days, Evelyne dives with the manta rays again. She almost dies while trying to free one ray from a net with her knife. Wai dives down to help her and the ray. When they return the next day, the manta ray appears again as if thanking them. The Makatean residents spend 10 days asking Profunda every question they can. As the referendum approaches, Didier tries to bring calm to the “chaos of democracy” (297). The residents make their final pitches before the voting rules are set. They have one final question for the AI machine: The residents want to know who’s behind the consortium. Profunda returns with profiles of the US businesspeople involved. When Rafi sees the name Todd Keane, he calls out in horror.
Over the course of Playground, Ina constructs a statue made of garbage that has washed up on the shores of Makatea. The garbage represents the corrosive, polluting influence of the world outside the island. No matter how much solar energy the people of Makatea may use or how little plastic they use in their daily lives, the rest of the world’s junk keeps washing up on their shores and polluting their island. Ina seeks to make a statue of this garbage, allowing her artistic inclinations to guide her as she assembles the gathered symbols of pollution into a totem of reclamation. The imposing garbage statue is striking, even if the local Makatean people can’t quite explain what they find so enthralling about Ina’s work of art. Later, the novel reveals this depiction of Makatea as an AI creation, is a story the AI device tells Todd to comfort him in his dying days. The residents’ inability to express their intrigue with Ina’s art speaks to AI’s inability to elaborate on the nuances of the human psyche, while the statue itself closely resembles one of the few works of art that Todd remembers Ina producing during their college days. The garbage sculpture echoes Ina’s earlier work, an iteration of something that already exists rather than something organically created. AI can’t create true art, at least in the way humans like Ina can. It can only reproduce or iterate upon existing works. This lack of creativity hints at the limitations of AI and foreshadows the ultimate failure of Todd’s AI project.
The people of Makatea have the opportunity to hold a referendum on their future. They can choose to accept or reject the US consortium’s plans to make Makatea the manufacturing base for the seasteading project. Like many other parts of the novel, the referendum presents the facade of democracy only to expose it as a hollow simulacrum of what it purports to be. The Makatean people simply can’t have all the information necessary to make such an important decision. The information they receive is from the consortium itself and includes the use of an AI machine that the islanders themselves consider a biased source of information. They’re trying to make sense of the world based only on the subjective narration of an interested party. In this respect, the referendum’s relationship with democracy mirrors the relationship between Todd’s subjective narration and objective truth. Like the choice the consortium offers the Makatean people, the story that the AI machine provides to them comes solely from a biased source. The Makatean people must confront this subjective version of reality because they have no other option. The hopeless gesture toward democracy echoes Todd’s doomed desire for resolution, as a false sense of objectivity predicates the referendum and the AI machine. Doubt lingers due to years of colonial oppression that wrought cultural, societal, and ecological destruction and had the effect of violence on the land, the people, and other species, thematically reflecting The Difficulty of Escaping Cycles of Violence.
In depicting the argument between Todd and Rafi, Todd’s subjectivity is clear. By his own admission, Todd is in love with Ina. When she comes to his apartment to seek his advice, he struggles to hide his feelings for her. When Rafi arrives the next day, Todd is ready to congratulate himself for sleeping on the floor. He’s proud of his refusal to countenance physical intimacy with his best friend’s partner. During the conversation, Rafi learns that Todd told Ina stories about Rafi’s childhood that Rafi never shared with anyone but Todd. Rafi expected his friend to keep their information private and feels utterly betrayed that the two people closest to him would conspire behind his back, especially when dealing in a currency that is particularly valuable to Rafi: his sense of vulnerability. Todd struggles to comprehend why Rafi won’t forgive him for this betrayal. He can’t empathize with Rafi’s vulnerability, instead becoming angry that trying to help his friends brought blame upon him. The rupture between them never heals, partly because Todd can’t comprehend exactly what he did wrong. His lack of understanding is evident when he repeats the betrayal by sharing every memory he has with the AI device, creating a databank of his dead friend’s most personal experiences in a way that would horrify Rafi if he were still alive. Rather than respect Rafi’s memory, Todd reiterates his mistake.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Richard Powers
Books & Literature
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Earth Day
View Collection
Education
View Collection
Fate
View Collection
Fathers
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Marriage
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Order & Chaos
View Collection
Popular Study Guides
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Teams & Gangs
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
The Booker Prizes Awardees & Honorees
View Collection