48 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
As the group ventures out for the night, Sydney feels jealousy over Maggie and Ridge’s relationship. She begins to cry. Warren comforts her, and Sydney notices Ridge’s jealousy. Two hours later, Sydney and Ridge find themselves alone in a booth while Warren and Maggie dance. Sydney asks Ridge why Maggie talks while Ridge does not. Ridge explains that Maggie has only mild hearing loss and divulges that he stopped speaking at the age of nine. After Sydney urges him to explain, Ridge shares that his parents had substance use disorders and never learned to sign using American Sign Language (ASL). Ridge taught Brennan how to sign so they could communicate. Forced to verbalize with his parents, Ridge stopped speaking after his father continually shamed him for his voice and once hit Brennan to make Ridge stop speaking. Saddened for him, Sydney begins to cry.
Drunk, Maggie and Warren return to the booth. Ridge and Sydney help Maggie and Warren out of the club. As Ridge helps him into the car, Warren says that Ridge likes Sydney. Ridge and Sydney share an intimate moment when he touches her back and helps her into the car.
Back at the apartment, Ridge helps put Warren and Maggie to bed. Ridge and Sydney eat together and continue their conversation. Sydney tells Ridge about her father’s expectations for her to follow in his footsteps and become a lawyer and her mother’s expectations for her to live independently. She also shares that she is paying for school on her own because her father refuses to help if she does not study law. Ridge provides more background information; he tells Sydney about how he became emancipated at the age of 16 and moved him and Brennan in with Warren’s family. Later, as the two watch a movie together, Ridge struggles with his guilt over his growing feelings for Sydney. They fall asleep on the couch.
Warren wakes Ridge early the next morning. Ridge returns to his room, embraces Maggie, and attempts to convince himself that he only has feelings for Maggie.
Weeks later, Ridge returns home after disappearing “for six days because of a family emergency” (168). Sydney focuses on school and grows closer to Warren, who confides in her about his love for Bridgette. One morning, Sydney confronts Bridgette, who still thinks Sydney is deaf, and Bridgette accuses Sydney of flirting with Warren. After Bridgette storms off, Sydney apologizes. As the two women bond, Sydney tells Bridgette about Warren’s feelings for her. Bridgette and Warren openly confess their love for each other and rush off. Sydney notices that Ridge seems preoccupied. They make plans to work on a song together later that evening.
Sydney and Ridge attempt to work on a song until Sydney leaves suddenly and throws her lyrics in the trash. Ridge retrieves them and realizes that the lyrics are about Sydney’s feelings for him. Eager to finish the song, he convinces Sydney to keep writing, advising her to write the lyrics from a male point of view.
Sydney rewrites the lyrics. Ridge adds to them and titles the song “Maybe Someday.” After reading Ridge’s additions to the song, she wonders about his feelings for her and grapples with her guilt. She leaves the room suddenly.
Ridge reflects on how his writer’s block lifted when he was writing about Sydney. He returns to his room and sends Brennan a rough draft of the song. Within the hour, Brennan sends Ridge a rough cut of the band singing “Maybe Someday.” Ridge plays it for Sydney and moves closer to her to feel the vibration of her singing. They share an intense kiss. When Sydney begins to sob, Ridge apologizes and leaves her room.
The next day, Sydney feels consumed with guilt and shame and ponders the strength of her desire for Ridge. Finally, Sydney exits her room and discovers Maggie and Ridge embracing in the living room. She shares that she arrived last night because her grandfather was admitted to the hospital, and then leaves quickly.
Sydney and Ridge meet in his bedroom and discuss what happened the night before. They decide to compose messages to each other and send them at the same time. In her message, Sydney expresses her deep feelings for Ridge, her hope that one day they could be together, and her commitment not to jump into another relationship so quickly. In his message, Ridge apologizes to her, declares that he will never leave Maggie, and reiterates how deeply he cares for Sydney. The two share embarrassing details about themselves to lessen their attractiveness to each other. They resolve to be friends and continue writing music together.
Sydney and Ridge continue to work together on their music as friends. Despite their boundaries, Sydney still struggles with her attraction to Ridge. One day, Hunter arrives unexpectedly at Sydney’s apartment and apologizes for his infidelity. He begs Sydney to take him back. When Ridge enters the living room, Hunter confronts Sydney about the nature of their relationship and calls her a hypocrite. Sydney derides Hunter for his accusation and asks him to leave.
After Hunter leaves, Ridge demands that Sydney never let Hunter in the apartment again. Upset, Sydney retreats to her bedroom crying and refuses to read Ridge’s texts. They grapple over Sydney’s phone, which she refuses to look at. Out of frustration, Ridge writes angrily on Sydney’s arm. She runs to the bathroom to wash off Ridge’s words. He helps her, apologizes, and suggests they write a song to help Sydney release her anger. Ridge and Sydney work on a song and collaborate on the lyrics together, which discuss temptation.
Sydney and Ridge share another intense moment where they come close to acting on their attraction. Hours later, Ridge shares a rough cut of their latest song with Sydney. They stare into each other’s eyes as they listen to the music.
Two weeks later, Ridge and Maggie chat. She will be visiting and staying with Ridge for two days. In preparation for Warren’s birthday party, Sydney and Ridge bake birthday cakes together. As they bake, Sydney asks Ridge about the meaning of the band’s name. Ridge notes how he has not told Maggie about the meaning even when she asked. While Ridge attempts to text the meaning to Sydney, he contemplates his undeniable feelings for both her and Maggie.
Ridge sends Sydney a message that explains the meaning of the band’s name, Sounds of Cedar. He explains that, when he and Brennan were younger, he would put his ear to the cedar floor of his bedroom to listen to the vibrations of his parents’ music while they partied. Once the music would stop, he would retrieve Brennan and bring him to his bedroom to take care of him. Ridge admits to Sydney that she is the first person to whom he has ever explained the name’s meaning.
Later that evening, Sydney and Ridge clean up and discuss Warren’s birthday party. When Ridge apologizes for placing Sydney in an awkward position with Maggie, Sydney jokes about having sex with Brennan. Ridge grows jealous. As Sydney attempts to apologize, Ridge embraces her. Their long embrace is interrupted by Warren’s return from work. To hide his words from Ridge, Warren turns his back to the pair and warns Sydney aloud that “[h]e will never leave her"—meaning Maggie—before retreating to his bedroom (246).
The next day, Ridge texts Brennan about the party and lightly warns him not to pursue Sydney. He enters the kitchen to help Sydney prepare for the party and does not notice Maggie watching him as he stares at Sydney from a distance. As the evening progresses, Maggie flirts with Ridge openly and uncharacteristically. When they are alone, Maggie casually confronts Ridge about his attraction to Sydney. He reassures her. When Maggie asks Ridge if he has told Sydney the truth about her, he says no.
Later that evening, a drunk Sydney wakes to find Maggie removing her clothing. She has vomited all over herself. Maggie is also drunk. The two women bond and return to the party to show off Sydney’s bra. Drunk, Sydney grows confused and calls Brennan Ridge before being escorted to the bathroom by Ridge. He puts Maggie and Sydney to sleep in his bed.
The next day, Ridge takes care of Maggie and Sydney. When Maggie falls asleep, Ridge checks in on Sydney. They share a tender moment and hold hands. Ridge wonders if Maggie and Sydney are both his soulmates. He also notes that he and Sydney’s souls are not “just compatible” but “perfectly attuned” (261). Sensing how much Sydney cares for him, Ridge writes on her palm and asks her to move out.
Sydney continues to sleep and doesn’t see the message on her palm. She wakes in the early morning and travels to the bathroom. As she surveys the apartment, she comes to the realization that she needs to move out so that she can “experience life on my own” (264). She enters the bathroom and discovers Maggie unconscious on the bathroom floor. Sydney calls 911 and struggles to communicate with Ridge about Maggie’s history and condition. Frustrated, Sydney wakes Warren who informs the operator that Maggie has CFRD, or cystic fibrosis-related diabetes. He retrieves a syringe from the refrigerator and injects Maggie as they wait for the ambulance.
After the paramedics rush Maggie to the hospital, Warren gathers Ridge’s belongings and prepares to drive Ridge to the hospital. Sydney insists on joining them despite Warren’s protests. At the hospital, she researches CFRD on her phone and learns about the shortened life expectancy for those who live with the condition. As she processes, she finally sees Ridge’s message on her palm.
Later, Ridge emerges from Maggie’s hospital room and updates Warren and Sydney on her condition. He informs them that Maggie will recover and that the alcohol and dehydration from vomiting contributed to problems with her blood sugar. Ridge notices Warren’s anger toward Sydney. He insists that Warren be nice to Sydney and returns to Maggie. Ridge and Maggie argue over his insistence that he follow her back to San Antonio and monitor her. Afraid to become a burden to Ridge, Maggie shares her desire to continue living independently so that Ridge will not have to take care of her.
Because of her own experiences with infidelity, Sydney struggles with her undeniable feelings for Ridge, who is deeply committed to Maggie. Hoover also continues to explore The Pursuit of Independence. Sydney grapples not only with her and Ridge’s potential betrayal of Maggie, but also with her need for autonomy, especially in the aftermath of her break-up with Hunter. As she and Ridge grow more intimate, Sydney attempts to balance this longing for independence with her growing feelings for Ridge. The song she and Ridge write together, “Maybe Someday,” captures Sydney’s deep feelings for Ridge and her desire to stay independent until she has had time to live alone. Hoover uses the song title as the novel’s title to convey the conflict between independence and intimacy that Sydney and Maggie struggle with throughout the novel.
This section continues to explore Music as Emotional Expression. Ridge and Maggie use the song “Maybe Someday” to communicate their feelings. While listening to the rough cut, they share their first kiss, a turning point in the novel that no longer allows Ridge and Sydney to deny their feelings. Ridge expresses a sense of relief as “every pent-up, denied feeling I’ve held towards her is suddenly uncaged, and I’m able to breathe for the first time since I’ve met her” (190). The song lyrics convey Ridge’s conflicting feelings for Maggie and Sydney: “For her I bend, for you I break” (185). The use of the word “break” shows the powerful influence she has on him. Yet despite his acknowledgment of Sydney’s impact, Ridge refuses to abandon his commitment to Maggie.
In this section of the novel, Hoover unveils the true reasons for Ridge’s undeterred loyalty to Maggie despite the strength of his connection with Sydney. He considers himself Maggie’s protector, and tries to convince Maggie to abandon her plans for independent living. Ridge’s name—a synonym for backbone—reflects a steadfastness in character, portrayed through his unwavering commitment to Maggie. However, ridges are at the edge of a peak, which suggests danger and excitement. Throughout the novel, Ridge finds himself at the edge between the stability of his relationship with Maggie and the excitement and exhilaration he experiences with Sydney. Here, readers see the theme of Passion Versus Stability. Ridge is torn by his desire to shield Maggie and the steadiness of their relationship versus his longing for Sydney.
While Ridge rejects the possibility of a relationship with Sydney, Sydney battles her conflicting feelings toward infidelity. At the beginning of the novel, in the aftermath of Tori and Hunter's betrayal, she has a strong moral stance against unfaithfulness. However, as she and Ridge grow closer, she begins to understand the complexities of adultery. The passionate kiss between Ridge and Sydney draws into question her own capacity for infidelity. When Ridge becomes consumed by guilt over their kiss, Sydney both respects Ridge’s commitment to Maggie and grieves his lack of commitment to her. Sydney reflects on the power of desire to consume “every part of you, enhancing your senses by a million” and to find satisfaction only in “the relief of another mouth in search of the same” (192).
By acknowledging the physical power of desire, Sydney begins to understand how Tori and Hunter could have betrayed her. Hunter is a mirror of Sydney when he arrives at Ridge’s apartment to beg for her forgiveness. After witnessing the connection between Ridge and Sydney, Hunter deems Sydney a hypocrite and asks Sydney, “How can you not see that what the two of you are doing isn’t any different from what Tori and I did” (212). Through Hunter’s confrontation, Sydney begins to recognize her own ability to succumb to desire.
Sydney is in a parallel role to Tori, and Maggie is in Sydney’s old position. Like Sydney, Maggie is unaware of the deep connection shared between her boyfriend and his friend, and desires not to be a burden and to live freely for herself. The connections between the two women also highlight their differences and emphasize how they are foils. Despite his deep love for both women, Ridge begins to tell Sydney his deepest traumas, which he has withheld from Maggie so as not to upset her. He comments on how “Sydney’s a different story” as “it’s easy to tell her things” (234). While Ridge fears hurting Maggie, he relies on Sydney and allows himself to be vulnerable.
Despite their growing physical and emotional intimacy, Sydney and Ridge are separated by her desire to live for herself and his devotion to protecting Maggie. Warren navigates between them as they attempt to seek help for Maggie. As a voice of reason, Warren tries to remind Sydney and Ridge how their connection would impact Maggie. While Sydney and Ridge continue to escape from the reality of their infidelity by absorbing themselves in songwriting, Hoover uses Warren to wake them to the harsh reality of what they are doing.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Colleen Hoover