logo

98 pages 3 hours read

Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2013

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Part 2, Chapters 7-11Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2: “Tending Sweetgrass”

Chapter 7 Summary: “Maple Sugar Moon”

The Anishinaabe Original Man is named Nanabozho; he walked through the world noting those who were following the “Original Instructions.” The Original Instructions are not commandments; rather, they are like a compass for how to interact with the natural world reciprocally and sustainably.

One day, Nanabozho found a lazy village where the people lay beneath maple trees all day, drinking syrup. To teach the villagers not to take natural resources for granted, Nanabozho took a bucket and diluted the sap. This is why today it takes 40 gallons of sap to make one gallon of syrup.

While living in upstate New York, the author and her two daughters, Linden and Larkin, set about making maple syrup. Rather than use the latest newfangled technology to extract the sap and turn it into syrup as easily and efficiently as possible, the author uses more difficult, traditional methods, as Nanabozho would have recommended. The family eagerly awaits signs of spring, though the trees, Kimmerer points out, “have a far more sophisticated system for detecting spring” (65). The family begins harvesting in April, finding the “scars of past taps” (65) already on the trees. They harvest the sap in buckets, build a fire, and boil the sap down to make syrup. By morning, however, four gallons of sap only produce a skin of syrup at the bottom of the pan.

After many nights’ work, the author and her daughters produce three quarts of syrup. Today, the author writes, her daughters “roll their eyes and groan” (69) at the memory of all the hard work. Yet this hard work is central to earning the bounty offered by the maple trees:

[Nanabozho’s] teachings remind us that one half of the truth is that the earth endows us with great gifts, the other half is that the gift is not enough. [...] The other half belongs to us; we participate in its transformation. It is our work, and our gratitude, that distills the sweetness (69).

Chapter 8 Summary: “Witch Hazel”

From her daughter’s perspective, Kimmerer tells a story about her old friend Hazel. Shortly after moving to Kentucky, they meet Hazel Barnett while picking berries. Hazel is “the oldest woman [her daughter had] ever seen” (73). The daughter worries that she might be a witch; nevertheless, her mother and Hazel become friends. Hazel lives in a small house with her disabled son Sam and daughter Janie, who is “simple.”

Hazel knows a great deal about the medicinal qualities of plants including witch hazel, a natural astringent and antiseptic often used to treat skin conditions. She was born nearby but moved in with Sam the night he suffered a heart attack. She misses her home, much like the author’s daughter knows her own mother misses her home.

One Christmas, the author prepares a surprise dinner at Hazel’s house. With the help of some of her students, Kimmerer cleans the house, arranges for the electricity to be temporarily restored, and invites the neighbors for a Christmas feast. When all is revealed, Hazel beams and “moved through her house like a queen” (80).

A few years later, the family leaves Kentucky. A few years after that, Hazel dies. The author’s daughter recollects how Hazel and her mother formed an unlikely friendship; they had “made a balm for their loneliness together” (81).

Chapter 9 Summary: “A Mother’s Work”

One day, the author’s husband decides to leave the country and his family behind permanently. Kimmerer searches for a new home in upstate New York with explicit instructions from her daughters to find a home with a purple bedroom. She takes it as a sign when she finds an old farmhouse with a purple bedroom, just as her daughters requested: “This is where we would fall to earth” (83). They move in and buy ducklings to be raised by the girls. Three ducks survive into adulthood, but before long they become a nuisance. They bully the dog and leave frozen defecations on the porch. Despite their annoying natures, the author cannot bring herself to be anything less than a “good mother” to them.

One day, the ducks disappear, leaving the pond thick with algae. After a pair of geese settle beside the pond, the author discovers a gosling trapped in the algae. It frees itself, but the author decides that she must clear the pond to make it more hospitable to wildlife. Coming at the issue from a scientific perspective, she begins to excavate the algae to prevent the chemical reaction which allows it to prosper.

During one such excavation, Kimmerer discovers hundreds of tadpoles in the pond. Struck by the moral dilemma, she faces the problem of letting the tadpoles—and other creatures—die in pursuit of a clean, swimmable pond. Each new process or change in the pond forces her to reconsider what she is doing. The process takes years, her life becoming entwined with the pond “in ways both material and spiritual” (95). Today, after 12 years, the pond is “nearly swimmable.” While the author’s daughters are now grown up and gone, she knows that it is her “grandchildren who will swim in this pond” (97).

Chapter 10 Summary: “The Consolation of Water Lilies”

While on a visit to see her older daughter Linden at her college in Northern California, Kimmerer walks along the nearby beach. She reflects on “the fundamental unfairness of parenthood” (98) and the fact that children will inevitably grow up and leave home. She spends much of her life feeding those in her charge: children, pet, fruits, vegetables, and flowers. She has a similar pang of emotion when Larkin, her younger daughter, also leaves for college.

To deal with these departures, the author purchases a new kayak. After taking Larkin to college, she drives straight to Labrador Pond and places the kayak on the water. She paddles through the lilies and rushes, pausing to float alone on the deep water. Satisfied, she rows to the shore and drives home. She arrives at her porch to find a stack of wrapped presents from Larkin. They are for the author, “one for every year of mothering Larkin” (104).

Chapter 11 Summary: “Allegiance to Gratitude”

One day, when her children are younger and still live at home, the author receives a call informing her that her daughter “refus[es] to stand with the class for the Pledge of Allegiance” (105). The call inspires the author to remember her own time in school; at the time, she felt “part of something” when reciting the Pledge of Allegiance, but now, she writes, “[T]he idea of asking schoolchildren to pledge loyalty to a political system seems exceedingly curious” (106). Moreover, it is difficult for Kimmerer and her daughter to celebrate America as a place of “liberty and justice for all” when their experiences as Indigenous people have proved otherwise.

At the time, the Kimmerer family house is located in “the ancestral homelands of the Onondaga Nation” (106) in upstate New York. Instead of the Pledge of Allegiance, the local Onondaga school recite the Thanksgiving Address each morning, a ritual expressing gratitude for the offerings of the natural world.

The author describes the various passages of the Thanksgiving Address, calling it “a lesson in Native science” (108). It thanks fish, plant life, berries, food plants, medicine herbs, trees, and much more. The Address can be tailored in length, and the listeners’ attention demonstrates gratitude. It is also a civics lesson, providing models of leadership “remind[ing] the whole community that leadership is rooted not in power and authority, but in service and wisdom” (112). While the Pledge of Allegiance imbues the author with a sense of cynicism over “the nation’s hypocrisy,” in the Address she hears respect given to “all of life.”

The author continues the Address, thanking the stars, the moon, and more. She asks the Onondaga whether she can write about their Address; they tell her “of course,” as it is supposed to be shared. The author longs for the day when people “can hear the land give thanks for the people in return” (118).

Part 2, Chapters 7-11 Analysis

In Part 2, the author introduces more autobiographical elements. Stories about her children, for example, widen the emotional range of her recollections and demonstrate that there can be bittersweet, joyous, and nostalgic dimensions to botany. She weaves these memories into the natural world. The memory of the pond, for example, illustrates how her concerted efforts to free the water of algae have a botanical, an academic, a traditional, a personal, and a narrative dimension. All of these strands combine as she takes more than a decade to clear away all of the algae. The process never really ends, but the author’s perspective changes. She understands that she is not necessarily working toward her own personal goal but toward an overarching, chronologically grander achievement. These added dimensions give her story weight and relevance, demonstrating the importance of combining academic knowledge with traditional understandings and personal investment.

Another example of this is the story told from the perspective of the author’s daughter. Before readers know the first daughter’s name, she gives a perspective on her mother’s friendship with a woman named Hazel. Seen from the child’s perspective, this friendship takes on a folkloric quality: The little girl wonders whether Hazel is a witch and then is able to see the qualities of a witch in her own mother. This narrative perspective emphasizes the emotional similarities between the author and Hazel; the audience sides with the more innocent—and perhaps more naïve—child’s view, seeing only the raw emotion in the relationship and not necessarily the complicating factors such as death and divorce.

This chapter, along with the chapters about the pond and about kayaking to cope with sending one’s children off to college, emphasize the importance of motherhood as a motif. This motif extends beyond human biological mothers to include mother earth, which feeds the author’s family sustenance through the maple sap they cook into syrup. Mother nature also provides the author emotional sustenance while she kayaks on the lake. Kimmerer writes, “I hadn’t realized that I had come to the lake and said feed me, but my empty heart was fed. I had a good mother. She gives what we need without being asked” (103).

The author sheds further light on the importance of perspective in her description of the Onondaga people’s Thanksgiving Address. Although this is already stated, it becomes even more evident that not all Indigenous people have the same beliefs. By incorporating these alternative Indigenous perspectives, the author demonstrates that she is not only talking about her own ancestors’ specific set of beliefs, but a wider cultural discourse which was shared by many Indigenous peoples. Moreover, the anecdote about the Thanksgiving Address offers yet another alternative social ritual, rooted in Indigenous culture, that the author believes should replace an existing ritual in mainstream America—in this case, the Pledge of Allegiance. Once again, the author hopes that Indigenous culture can supplement non-Indigenous norms for the purpose of creating a more harmonious and reciprocal relationship between humanity and nature.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 98 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools